The Witch (2015)

thew12016.78: The Witch (Amazon VOD)

The Witch is a superior horror film but also a divisive one.  There are a few jumpy scares, little gore- its not THAT kind of horror film. Instead its really more about conveying  an ever-deepening sense of dread. Its a beautifully-shot film dripping with mood and atmosphere and slowly rising terror, but the slow pace, and lack of defined ‘evil’ (or even ‘good’) seems to have alienated many. Modern audiences don’t seem to handle ambiguity or invitation to interpretation very well. For myself, well, I absolutely adored it, and was then quite dumbfounded to learn of so many negative opinions of the film,  so much so I wondered if I had seen the same film. Of course I had- indeed the very same things I loved about the film, the archaic old English being spoken, the attitudes and behaviour of characters of their own time, the slow pace, the sense of unsettling mood and the utterly unexplained horror that befalls the characters, all the things I loved, were the same things that detractors hated in their comments/reviews. Shockingly, some people even walked out of screenings during the films cinema release.

Dubbed A New England Folk Tale, according to the title screen at the start of the film, it tells the story of a 17th-Century puritanical English family who have moved to the New World. Banished from their settlement due to some undefined dispute with the Church Elders, the family  set out into the unexplored, untamed wilderness and build a homestead and farm near some wild woods. Several months after settling there, the youngest child -scarcely a baby- is mysteriously taken by some vague supernatural figure (‘the Witch’ of the title) and suffers some awful end in a bloody rite.

thew2The family, ignorant of the supernatural presence looming in the depths of the nearby woods, simply think the infant has been snatched by a wolf and are consumed with guilt as if this tragedy has been brought about by Gods judgement of them. As the crops fail and other maladies befall them, this sense of guilt and self-loathing intensifies and the family start to turn on each other. In tone it feels like Kubrick’s The Shining mixed up with elements from all sorts of European folk tales (the Witch raises from her lair looking like Red Riding Hood at one point). It looks bizarrely ravishing in a grey, dreary, monochrome way, and sounds utterly horrifying (an unnerving soundtrack of period instruments coupled with wailing reminiscent of György Ligeti’s atmospheres in 2001: A Space Odyssey).

Its a nightmare of puritanical guilt, a family consumed by their faith and religion, the darkness of their wild surroundings settling into their hearts, as if the land is itself turning upon them. Is it actually a Witch terrorising them (she never speaks, or has her actions explained, and is only fleetingly glimpsed) or is it simply the Puritans own guilt and self-loathing manifested in the shadows, externalised into something that truly only exists in their minds?

Based on all sorts of folklore and memoirs, it hearkens back to real history, of settlers in the New World struggling through the horrors of famine and disease and child mortality,the brutal testing of their Faith eventually culminating in tales of Witchcraft (and the resulting Salem Witch-trials ).

thew3The characters all seem very real; they are of their time, never really behaving or reasoning things out as modern people would (hence the frustrations, I expect, of some audiences). Its a reminder that most period films are simply transposing modern people into historical tableau- something simply not the case here. The sense of place and time is utterly convincing; the period details are rich and seem authentic, and some of the imagery is quite amazing (and very disturbing). Its a genuinely unsettling, really gripping horror film and one of the best films I have seen this year. I’ll cautiously recommend it as I can appreciate its rather divisive, but crikey, what a horror film. It really gets under your skin (well, it did mine anyway, and I’ve been endlessly thinking about it ever since I saw it.)

Simply brilliant.

7 thoughts on “The Witch (2015)

  1. Tom

    Cool to see another fan of The Witch. I loved it too, for all the reasons you list here. It’s one of the most atmospheric and original experiences I’ve had in a horror film in some time. I think the decision to speak the dialogue in Olde English was fantastic, albeit it did limit my understanding of some of the things that were being said. Not enough to limit my enjoyment though. This thing was s-p-o-o-k-y!

    1. Cheers Tom. Its great to see a horror film thats genuinely moody and unsettling. Too many these days rely on shock tactics and graphic gore. This film is more about time and place and the fact it feels so authentic ensures the horror aspects work. I enjoyed the sense of mystery too- the titular Witch is an enigma and the ending leaves me wondering if it was all about turning one particular soul from God.

      1. Tom

        Yeah for sure. Plus there’s just something inherently creepy and weird about puritanical life. I’d gladly watch this again

  2. Matthew McKinnon

    I had a tough time with this, I must say.
    I was very keen to see it – and there was such a long wait between hearing about it (back in late 2014, I think?) and eventually seeing it, sharpening the anticipation.

    In theory it does so many things right – it looks and sounds great, it makes no bones about having a supernatural presence right from the start (none of this ‘is it, isn’t it?’ guff that pads out other ‘highbrow’ horror films). And I’m all for a film that gets online morons angry because it’s unusual, doesn’t have the requisite jump-scares etc etc.

    But… but… it didn’t work for us (myself and my wife went to see it in a cinema and came out with the same feeling). It just didn’t land.

    Part of it is the accents: why do the other family members, particularly Kate Dickie who in real life has a broad Scots accent, have to pretend to have the same regional accent as the father – especially when it proves difficult for them to sustain? The child acting in a few places just isn’t good enough, so quite a few scenes deflate as you’re watching them. And the pacing was sluggish and a little self-important in places.

    I feel bad not appreciating it, because on paper it sounds wonderful; but the heart can’t be fooled, and I can’t bring myself to like it.

    Still. I bought the soundtrack.

    1. It is a funny thing, what ‘clicks’ and what doesnt. I think its sometimes an emotional connection or even something as daft as what mood I’m in, and expectations too. I can watch a film deemed ‘great’ and be disappointed or watch a ‘poor’ film and be pleasantly surprised. I guess some films, no matter how good, just don’t ‘work’ on some subjective level, a sense of personal taste difficult to quantify.

      With The Witch I knew nothing about it, and infact had it mixed up with a Natalie Dormer horror flick titled The Forest (aha, future review coming soon), so it worked a spell on me. But as I mentioned on the review I can see its a divisive film. I certainly appreciate it for the fact it doesnt reach for some middle ground, instead being true to itself.

  3. Pingback: The Conjuring (2013) – the ghost of 82

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s